artabro/wire/modules/Process/ProcessCommentsManager/ProcessCommentsManager.module

<?php namespace ProcessWire;

/**
 * Comments Manager
 *
 * Manage all comments field data in chronological order. 
 *
 * ProcessWire 3.x 
 * Copyright (C) 2022 by Ryan Cramer 
 * This file licensed under Mozilla Public License v2.0 http://mozilla.org/MPL/2.0/
 * 
 * https://processwire.com
 * 
 * @method string renderComment(Comment $comment, array $options = array())
 *
 */

class ProcessCommentsManager extends Process {

	/**
	 * Return information about this module (required)
	 *
	 */
	public static function getModuleInfo() {
		return array(
			'title' => __('Comments', __FILE__), 
			'summary' => __('Manage comments in your site outside of the page editor.', __FILE__),
			'version' => 12, 
			'author' => 'Ryan Cramer', 
			'icon' => 'comments', 
			'requires' => 'FieldtypeComments',
			'searchable' => 'comments', 
			'permission' => 'comments-manager', 
			'permissions' => array(
				'comments-manager' => 'Use the comments manager', 
				),
			'page' => array(
				'name' => 'comments',
				'parent' => 'setup', 
				'title' => 'Comments', 
				),
			'nav' => array(
				array(
					'url' => '?go=approved',
					'label' => __('Approved', __FILE__),
					),
				array(
					'url' => '?go=pending',
					'label' => __('Pending', __FILE__),
					), 
				array(
					'url' => '?go=spam',
					'label' => __('Spam', __FILE__),
					),
				array(
					'url' => '?go=all',
					'label' => __('All', __FILE__),
					)
				)
			); 
	}


	/**
	 * Statuses and names that a Comment can have
	 *
	 */
	protected $statuses = array();

	/**
	 * Translated statuses
	 *
	 */
	protected $statusTranslations = array();

	/**
	 * Translated flags 
	 * 
	 * @var array
	 * 
	 */
	protected $notifyFlagsTranslations = array();

	/**
	 * Number of comments to show per page
	 *
	 */
	protected $limit = 10;

	/**
	 * Headline for masthead
	 *
	 */
	protected $headline = '';

	/**
	 * Translated 'All' label
	 * 
	 * @var string
	 * 
	 */
	protected $labelAll = 'All';

	/**
	 * Initialize the comments manager and define the statuses
	 *
	 */
	public function init() {
		$this->wire()->modules->get('FieldtypeComments');
		parent::init();
		$this->statuses = array(
			Comment::statusFeatured => 'featured',
			Comment::statusApproved => 'approved',
			Comment::statusPending => 'pending',
			Comment::statusSpam => 'spam',
			Comment::statusDelete => 'delete'
		);
		$this->statusTranslations = array(
			Comment::statusFeatured => $this->_('Featured'),
			Comment::statusApproved => $this->_('Approved'),
			Comment::statusPending => $this->_('Pending'),
			Comment::statusSpam => $this->_('Spam'),
			Comment::statusDelete => $this->_('Delete')
		);
		$this->labelAll = $this->_('All');
		$this->notifyFlagsTranslations = array(
			0 => $this->_('No'), 
			Comment::flagNotifyAll => $this->labelAll,
			Comment::flagNotifyReply => $this->_('Replies'), 
		);
		if(wireClassExists("CommentStars")) {
			$config = $this->config;
			$cssFile = $config->urls('FieldtypeComments') . 'comments.css';
			$jsFile = $config->urls('FieldtypeComments') . 'comments.js';
			$config->styles->add($cssFile);
			$config->scripts->add($jsFile);
			CommentStars::setDefault('star', wireIconMarkup('star'));
		}
	}

	/**
	 * Ask the user to select which comments field they want to manage
 	 *
	 * Or, redirect to the comments field if there is only 1.
	 * 
	 * @return string
	 *
	 */
	public function ___execute() {
		$this->checkInstall();
		// locate all the FieldtypeComments fields
		$fields = array();
		foreach($this->fields as $field) {
			/** @var Field $field */
			if($field->type instanceof FieldtypeComments) $fields[] = $field;
		}

		$count = count($fields);

		if(!$count) {
			$error = $this->_('There are no comments fields installed');
			$this->error($error);
			return "<p>$error</p>";
		}
		
		$go = $this->wire()->sanitizer->pageName($this->wire('input')->get('go')); 

		if($count == 1 || $go) {
			$field = reset($fields);
			$to = 'all';
			if($go && in_array($go, $this->statuses)) $to = $go;
			$this->wire()->session->redirect("./list/$field->name/$to/"); 
			return '';
		}

		$out = "<h2>" . $this->_('Please select a comments field') . "</h2><ul>";
		foreach($fields as $field) {
			$out .= "<li><a href='./list/$field->name/pending/'>$field->name</a></li>";
		}
		$out .= "</ul>";

		return $out;
	}	

	/**
	 * Execute the comments list 
	 * 
	 * @return string
	 *
	 */
	public function ___executeList() {

		$session = $this->wire('session'); /** @var Session $session */
		$input = $this->wire('input'); /** @var WireInput $input */
		$sanitizer = $this->wire('sanitizer'); /** @var Sanitizer $sanitizer */
		$page = $this->wire('page'); /** @var Page $page */

		$commentID = (int) $input->get('id');
		$name = $sanitizer->fieldName($input->urlSegment2); 
		if(!$name) return $this->error($this->_('No comments field specified in URL')); 
		$field = $this->fields->get($name); 
		if(!$field || !$field->type instanceof FieldtypeComments) return $this->error($this->_('Unrecognized field')); 
		$status = $input->urlSegment3;
		
		if(empty($status) || ($status != 'all' && !in_array($status, $this->statuses))) {
			$redirectUrl = $page->url() . "list/$field->name/all/";
			if($commentID) $redirectUrl .= "?id=$commentID";
			$session->redirect($redirectUrl); 
		}
		
		$statusNum = array_search($status, $this->statuses); 
		$headline = $statusNum !== false ? $this->statusTranslations[$statusNum] : $status; 
		if($headline === 'all') $headline = $this->labelAll;
		$this->breadcrumb('../', $field->getLabel());

		$limit = (int) $input->get('limit');
		if($limit) {
			$session->setFor($this, 'limit', $limit);
			$session->redirect('./');
		} else {
			$limit = (int) $session->getFor($this, 'limit');
			if(!$limit) $limit = (int) $this->limit;
		}
		$sort = $sanitizer->name($input->get('sort'));
		if($sort) {
			$session->setFor($this, 'sort', $sort);
			$session->redirect('./');
		} else {
			$sort = $session->getFor($this, 'sort');
			if(!$sort) $sort = '-created';
		}
	
		$start = ($input->pageNum() - 1) * $limit;
		$selector = "start=$start, limit=$limit, sort=$sort";
		if($status != 'all') $selector .= ", status=$statusNum";

		$filterOut = '';
		$filterLabels = array(
			'id' => $this->_('ID'),
			'parent_id' => $this->_('Replies to'), 
			'pages_id' => $this->_('Page'), 
		);

		$properties = array(
			'cite', 
			'email', 
			'text', 
			'ip', 
			'id', 
			'pages_id',
			'parent_id', 
			'stars'
		);
		
		$q = $input->get('q');
		if($q !== null) {
			// query $q that contain a selector 
			$q = trim($sanitizer->text($q, array('stripTags' => false)));
			$op = Selectors::stringHasOperator($q, true);
			if($op) {
				list($property, $value) = explode($op, $q, 2); 
				$property = $sanitizer->fieldName($property);
				if(!in_array($property, $properties)) $property = '';
			} else {
				$property = 'text';
				$op = strpos($q, ' ') ? '~=' : '%=';
				$value = $q;
			}
			if($property && $value) {
				$selector .= ", $property$op" . $sanitizer->selectorValue($value);
				$input->whitelist('q', "$property$op$value"); 
			}
			$filterOut .= $sanitizer->entities(", $property$op$value"); 
		} 
		
		foreach($properties as $key) {
			$value = $input->get($key);
			if(is_null($value)) continue;
			if($key == 'id' || $key == 'pages_id' || $key == 'parent_id' || $key == 'stars') {
				$value = (int) $value;
			} else {
				$value = trim($sanitizer->text($value));
			}
			$input->whitelist($key, $value);
			$value = $sanitizer->selectorValue($value);
			$selector .= ", $key=$value";
			$filterLabel = isset($filterLabels[$key]) ? $filterLabels[$key] : ucfirst($key);
			$filterOut .= $sanitizer->entities(", $filterLabel: $value");
		}

		/** @var FieldtypeComments $fieldtype */
		$fieldtype = $field->type; 
		$comments = $fieldtype->find($field, $selector); 
		if($input->post('processComments')) {
			$this->processComments($comments, $field);
		}
		if($filterOut) {
			$this->breadcrumb('./', $headline); 
			$headline = trim($filterOut, ", "); 
		}
		$this->headline = $headline; 
		
		return $this->renderComments($comments); 
	}

	/**
	 * Execute the comment meta viewer/editor
	 * 
	 * @return string
	 * @since 3.0.203
	 * 
	 */
	public function ___executeMeta() {
		$input = $this->wire()->input; 
		$commentId = (int) $input->get('comment_id'); 
		$fieldId = (int) $input->get('field_id');
		$pageId = (int) $input->get('page_id'); 
		$modal = (int) $input->get('modal');
		
		if($commentId < 1 || $fieldId < 1 || $pageId < 1) {
			throw new WireException("Missing one of: comment_id, field_id, page_id");
		}
		
		$field = $this->wire()->fields->get($fieldId);
		$fieldtype = $field->type; /** @var FieldtypeComments $fieldtype */
		if(!$field || (!$fieldtype instanceof FieldtypeComments)) {
			throw new WireException("Invalid field specified");
		}	
		
		$page = $this->wire()->pages->get($pageId); 
		if(!$page->id || !$page->hasField($field) || !$page->editable($field)) {
			throw new WireException("Invalid or non-editable page specified");
		}
		
		$comment = $fieldtype->getCommentByID($page, $field, $commentId); 
		if(!$comment) throw new WireException("Cannot find comment $commentId"); 
	
		$meta = $comment->getMeta();
		$flags = JSON_PRETTY_PRINT | JSON_UNESCAPED_UNICODE | JSON_UNESCAPED_SLASHES; 
		if(defined('JSON_UNESCAPED_LINE_TERMINATORS')) $flags = $flags | JSON_UNESCAPED_LINE_TERMINATORS;
		$metaJSON = empty($meta) ? '{ }' : json_encode($meta, $flags); 
		$numRows = substr_count($metaJSON, "\n")+1; 
		if($numRows < 10) $numRows = 10;
	
		$this->headline(sprintf($this->_('Meta data for comment #%d'), $commentId)); 
		if(empty($meta)) $this->message($this->_('Comment currently has no meta data')); 
		// $out = "<pre id='meta-preview'>$metaEncodedJSON</pre>";
	
		$modules = $this->wire()->modules;
		
		/** @var InputfieldForm $form */
		$form = $modules->get('InputfieldForm'); 
		$form->attr('method', 'post');
		$form->attr('action', "./?comment_id=$commentId&page_id=$pageId&field_id=$fieldId&modal=$modal");
		
		/** @var InputfieldTextarea $f */
		$f = $modules->get('InputfieldTextarea'); 
		$f->attr('name', 'meta');
		$f->label = $this->_('Meta JSON editor'); 
		$f->val($metaJSON); 
		$f->attr('rows', $numRows); 
		$f->attr('style', "font-family:monospace;"); 
		$form->add($f);
	
		/** @var InputfieldSubmit $f */
		$f = $modules->get('InputfieldSubmit');
		$f->attr('name', 'submit_save'); 
		$f->val($this->_('Save changes')); 
		$form->add($f);
		
		/** @var InputfieldSubmit $f */
		$f = $modules->get('InputfieldButton');
		$f->attr('name', 'submit_cancel'); 
		$f->setSecondary();
		$f->val($this->_('Cancel'));
		$form->add($f);
		
		if($input->post('submit_save')) {
			$session = $this->wire()->session;
			$form->processInput($input->post); 
			$metaInput = $form->getChildByName('meta');
			$metaSaveJSON = $metaInput->val();
			if($metaSaveJSON === $metaJSON) {
				$this->message($this->_('No changes detected'));
				$session->redirect($form->attr('action'));
			} else {
				$meta = json_decode($metaSaveJSON, true);
				if(is_array($meta)) {
					$result = $fieldtype->updateComment($page, $field, $comment, array('meta' => $meta));
					if($result) {
						$this->message(sprintf($this->_('Updated meta for comment #%d'), $commentId));
						$session->redirect($form->attr('action'));
					} else {
						$this->error(sprintf($this->_('Error updating meta for comment #%d'), $commentId));
					}
				} else {
					$this->error($this->_('Cannot save because invalid JSON'));
				}
			}
		}

		$out = $form->render();
		
		return $out;
	}

	/**
	 * Edit or add comment
	 * 
	 * @return string
	 * @throws WireException
	 * @throws WirePermissionException
	 * 
	 */
	protected function ___executeEdit() {
	
		$sanitizer = $this->wire()->sanitizer; 
		$input = $this->wire()->input;
		$user = $this->wire()->user;
		$submit = false;
		$out = '';
	
		if($input->post('submit_save_comment')) {
			$submit = true;
			$pageId = (int) $input->post('page_id');
			$fieldId = (int) $input->post('field_id');
			$parentId = (int) $input->post('parent_id');
			$commentId = (int) $input->post('comment_id');
		} else {
			$pageId = (int) $input->get('page_id');
			$fieldId = (int) $input->get('field_id');
			$parentId = (int) $input->get('parent_id');
			$commentId = (int) $input->get('comment_id');
		}
		
		$page = $this->wire()->pages->get($pageId);
		$field = $this->wire()->fields->get($fieldId); /** @var CommentField $field */

		if(!$page->id) throw new WireException("Cannot find page $pageId"); 
		if(!$field) throw new WireException("Cannot find field $fieldId"); 
		if(!$page->hasField($field)) throw new WireException("Page $pageId does not have field $field->name"); 
	
		if($commentId) {
			// editing existing comment
			$comment = $field->getCommentByID($page, $commentId); 
			if(!$comment) throw new WireException('Comment not found');
			if($comment->getField()->id != $field->id) throw new WireException('Invalid field');
			if($comment->getPage()->id != $page->id) throw new WireException('Invalid page');
			$this->headline(sprintf($this->_('Edit comment #%d'), $comment->id)); 
			
		} else {
			// adding new comment
			$comment = new Comment();
			$this->wire($comment);
			$comment->setPage($page);
			$comment->setField($field);
			$comment->cite = $user->get('title|name');
			$comment->email = $user->get('email'); 
			$comment->created = time();
			$comment->status = Comment::statusApproved; 
			if($parentId) {
				// new comment that is reply to existing comment
				$parentComment = $field->getCommentByID($page, $parentId); 
				if(!$parentComment) throw new WireException("Cannot find parent comment $parentId");
				$comment->parent_id = $parentId;
				$this->headline(sprintf($this->_('Comment #%d by %s'), $parentId, $parentComment->getFormatted('cite'))); 
				// show comment being replied to
				$text = $sanitizer->entities1($parentComment->getFormattedCommentText());
				$when = date('Y/m/d H:i', $parentComment->created) . ' • ' . wireRelativeTimeStr($parentComment->created);
				$out .= "<p class='detail'>$when</p>";
				$out .= "<blockquote><p>$text</p></blockquote>";
				$out .= "<h2>" . $this->_('Your reply') . "</h2>";
			}
		}

		$form = $this->buildEditForm($page, $field, $comment);
		
		if($submit) {
			$this->processEditForm($form, $page, $field, $comment);
		}
	
		return $out . $form->render();
	}

	/**
	 * Process comment edit form 
	 * 
	 * @param InputfieldForm $form
	 * @param Page $page
	 * @param CommentField $field
	 * @param Comment $comment
	 * @return bool
	 * 
	 */
	protected function processEditForm(InputfieldForm $form, Page $page, CommentField $field, Comment $comment) {
		
		$input = $this->wire()->input;

		$form->processInput($input->post); 
		if(count($form->getErrors())) return false;

		$values = array();
		$properties = array(
			'cite', 
			'email', 
			'website', 
			'text', 
			'created', 
			'status'
		);
		
		if($field->useVotes) {
			$properties[] = 'upvotes';
			$properties[] = 'downvotes';
		}
		
		foreach($properties as $name) {
			$f = $form->getChildByName($name);
			if(!$f) continue;
			$value = $f->val();
			if($value != $comment->get($name)) {
				$comment->set($name, $value);
				$values[$name] = $value;
			}
		}
		
		if($field->useStars) {
			$stars = (int) $input->post('stars');
			if($stars != $comment->stars && $stars > 0 && $stars <= 5) {
				$comment->stars = $stars;
				$values['stars'] = $stars;
			}
		}

		$f = $field->useNotify ? $form->getChildByName('notify_author') : null; 
		if($f) {
			$notify = (int) $f->val();
			if($this->applyCommentNotifyFlag($comment, $notify)) {
				$values['flags'] = $comment->flags;
			}
		}

		/** @var Inputfield $f */
		$f = $form->getChildByName('page_id');
		$pageId = $f->val();
		if($pageId != $page->id) {
			$f->error('Changing page is not currently supported with this form');
			return false;
			/*
			$newPage = $this->wire()->pages->get($pageId); 
			if(!$newPage->editable()) {
				$f->error($this->_('Selected page is not editable')); 
				return false;
			}
			if(!$newPage->hasField($field)) {
				$f->error(sprintf($this->_('Selected page does not have field: %s'), $field->name)); 
				return false;
			}
			*/
		}
		

		if($comment->id) {
			// existing comment
			if($comment->status === Comment::statusDelete) {
				$success = $field->deleteComment($page, $comment);
				if($success) {
					$this->message(sprintf($this->_('Deleted comment #%d'), $comment->id));
					$this->wire()->session->location("../list/$field->name/all/");
				}
			} else {
				$success = $field->updateComment($page, $comment, $values);
				if($success) $this->message(sprintf($this->_('Updated comment #%d'), $comment->id));
			}
		} else {
			// new comment
			/** @var Inputfield $f */
			$f = $form->getChildByName('notify');
			$notify = $f && $f->val();
			$comment->status = Comment::statusApproved;
			$success = $field->addComment($page, $comment, $notify);
			if($success) $this->message(sprintf($this->_('Added comment #%d'), $comment->id));
		}

		if($success) {
			$this->wire()->session->location("../list/$field->name/all/?id=$comment->id");
		} else {
			$this->error($this->_('Error saving comment'));
		}
		
		return $success;
	}

	/**
	 * Build comment edit/add form
	 * 
	 * @param Page $page
	 * @param CommentField $field
	 * @param Comment $comment
	 * @return InputfieldForm
	 * 
	 */
	protected function buildEditForm(Page $page, CommentField $field, Comment $comment) {
		
		$modules = $this->wire()->modules;
		
		/** @var InputfieldForm $form */
		$form = $modules->get('InputfieldForm');

		/** @var InputfieldText $f */
		$f = $modules->get('InputfieldText');
		$f->attr('name', 'cite');
		$f->label = $this->_('Cite / author');
		$f->val($comment->cite);
		$f->required = true;
		$f->columnWidth = 50;
		$form->add($f);

		/** @var InputfieldEmail $f */
		$f = $modules->get('InputfieldEmail');
		$f->attr('name', 'email');
		$f->label = $this->_('Email');
		$f->val($comment->email);
		$f->columnWidth = 50;
		$f->required = true;
		$form->add($f);
		
		/** @var InputfieldSelect $f */
		$f = $modules->get('InputfieldSelect');
		$f->attr('name', 'status');
		$f->label = $this->_('Status');
		$f->required = true;
		foreach($this->statusTranslations as $status => $statusText) {
			$f->addOption($status, $statusText);
		}
		$f->val($comment->status);
		$f->columnWidth = 50;
		$form->add($f);

		/** @var InputfieldDatetime $f */
		$f = $modules->get('InputfieldDatetime');
		$f->attr('name', 'created');
		$f->label = $this->_('Created');
		$f->inputType = 'html';
		$f->htmlType = 'datetime';
		$f->val($comment->created);
		$f->required = true;
		$f->columnWidth = 50;
		$form->add($f);

		if($field->useWebsite) {
			/** @var InputfieldText $f */
			$f = $modules->get('InputfieldUrl');
			$f->attr('name', 'website');
			$f->label = $this->_('Website/URL');
			$f->val($comment->website);
			$form->add($f);
		}

		/** @var InputfieldTextarea $f */
		$f = $modules->get('InputfieldTextarea');
		$f->attr('name', 'text');
		$f->label = $this->_('Text');
		$f->val($comment->text);
		$f->attr('rows', 10);
		$f->required = true;
		$form->add($f);
		
		if($field->useVotes) {
			/** @var InputfieldInteger $f */
			$f = $modules->get('InputfieldInteger'); 
			$f->attr('name', 'upvotes'); 
			$f->label = $this->_('Upvotes'); 
			$f->val($comment->upvotes); 
			$f->columnWidth = $field->useStars ? 25 : 50;
			$f->inputType = 'number';
			$form->add($f);
			
			/** @var InputfieldInteger $f */
			$f = $modules->get('InputfieldInteger');
			$f->attr('name', 'downvotes');
			$f->label = $this->_('Downvotes');
			$f->val($comment->upvotes);
			$f->columnWidth = $field->useStars ? 25 : 50;
			$f->inputType = 'number';
			$form->add($f);
		}
		
		if($field->useStars) {
			/** @var InputfieldMarkup $f */
			$f = $modules->get('InputfieldMarkup');
			$f->attr('name', 'stars');
			$f->label = $this->_('Stars');
			$f->value =
				"<input type='hidden' name='stars' value='$comment->stars' />" .
				$comment->renderStars(array('input' => true));
			if($field->useVotes) $f->columnWidth = 50; 
			$form->add($f);
		}


		/** @var InputfieldRadios $f */
		$f = $modules->get('InputfieldRadios');
		$f->attr('name', 'notify_author');
		$f->label = $this->_('Notify the email listed above when');
		$f->addOption(0, $this->_('Never'));
		if($field->depth) $f->addOption(Comment::flagNotifyReply, $this->_('There is a reply to this comment'));
		$f->addOption(Comment::flagNotifyAll, $this->_('Anytime a new comment is posted on this page'));
		if($comment->flags & Comment::flagNotifyAll) {
			$f->val(Comment::flagNotifyAll);
		} else if($comment->flags & Comment::flagNotifyReply) {
			$f->val(Comment::flagNotifyReply);
		} else {
			$f->val(0);
		}
		$form->add($f);

		/** @var InputfieldToggle $f */
		if(!$comment->id) {
			$f->columnWidth = 50;
			$f = $modules->get('InputfieldToggle');
			$f->attr('name', 'notify');
			$f->label = $this->_('Allow notifications to others?');
			$f->detail = $this->_('When “Yes”, emails about this new comment will be sent to users that have opted in to receive notifications.'); 
			$f->val(true);
			$f->columnWidth = 50;
			$form->add($f);
		}
		
		/** @var InputfieldPageListSelect $f */
		/*
		$f = $modules->get('InputfieldPageListSelect'); 
		$f->attr('name', 'page_id'); 
		$f->label = $this->_('Page'); 
		$f->val($page->id);
		$form->add($f);
		*/

		/** @var InputfieldHidden $f */
		$f = $modules->get('InputfieldHidden');
		$f->attr('name', 'page_id');
		$f->val($page->id);
		$form->add($f);

		/** @var InputfieldHidden $f */
		$f = $modules->get('InputfieldHidden');
		$f->attr('name', 'field_id');
		$f->val($field->id);
		$form->add($f);
		
		/** @var InputfieldHidden $f */
		$f = $modules->get('InputfieldHidden');
		$f->attr('name', 'comment_id');
		$f->val($comment->id);
		$form->add($f);

		/** @var InputfieldHidden $f */
		$f = $modules->get('InputfieldHidden');
		$f->attr('name', 'parent_id');
		$f->val($comment->parent_id);
		$form->add($f);

		/** @var InputfieldSubmit $f */
		$f = $modules->get('InputfieldSubmit');
		$f->attr('name', 'submit_save_comment');
		$f->showInHeader();
		$form->add($f);
		
		return $form;
	}


	/**
	 * Process changes to posted comments
	 * 
	 * @param CommentArray $comments
	 * @param CommentField $field
	 *
	 */
	protected function processComments(CommentArray $comments, Field $field) {
		
		$input = $this->wire()->input;

		$numDeleted = 0;
		$numChanged = 0;
		$isSuperuser = $this->user->isSuperuser();
		$allowChangeParent = $isSuperuser && $field->get('depth') > 0;
		$allowChangePage = $isSuperuser;
		$commentField = $field instanceof CommentField ? $field : null;
		
		/** @var FieldtypeComments $fieldtype */
		$fieldtype = $field->type;

		foreach($comments as $comment) {
			/** @var Comment $comment */

			$properties = array();

			$text = $input->post("CommentText$comment->id"); 
			if(!is_null($text) && $text != $comment->text) {
				$comment->text = $text; // cleans it
				$properties['text'] = $comment->text;
				$numChanged++;
			}

			if($field->get('useVotes')) { 
				foreach(array("upvotes", "downvotes") as $name) {
					$votes = $input->post("Comment" . ucfirst($name) . $comment->id);
					if($votes !== null) {
						$votes = (int) $votes;
						if($votes != $comment->$name) {
							$comment->set($name, $votes);
							$properties[$name] = $comment->$name;
							$numChanged++;
						}
					}
				}
			}
			
			if($field->get('useStars')) {
				$stars = $input->post("CommentStars$comment->id");
				if($stars !== null) {
					$stars = (int) $stars;
					if($stars != $comment->stars) {
						$comment->set('stars', $stars);
						$properties['stars'] = $comment->stars;
						$numChanged++;
					}
				}
			}

			$_status = $input->post("CommentStatus$comment->id"); 
			$status = (int) $_status;
			if($status === Comment::statusDelete && (!$commentField || $commentField->allowDeleteComment($comment))) {
				if($fieldtype->deleteComment($comment->getPage(), $field, $comment)) {
					$this->message(sprintf($this->_('Deleted comment #%d'), $comment->id)); 
					$numDeleted++;
				}
				continue; 
			}
			
			if($_status !== null && $status !== (int) $comment->status && array_key_exists($status, $this->statuses)) {
				$comment->status = $status; 
				$numChanged++;
				$properties['status'] = $comment->status;
			}
		
			$notify = $input->post("CommentNotify$comment->id"); 
			if($notify !== null && $field->useNotify && ctype_digit($notify)) {
				$notify = (int) $notify;
				if($this->applyCommentNotifyFlag($comment, $notify)) {
					$properties['flags'] = $comment->flags;
				}
			}
			
			$changePage = null;
			if($allowChangePage) {
				// check for change of Page ID
				$pageID = (int) $input->post("CommentPage$comment->id"); 
				if($pageID > 0 && "$pageID" !== "$comment->page") {
					$page = $this->wire()->pages->get($pageID); 
					$parentID = $comment->parent_id;
					if($parentID) $comment->parent_id = 0; // temporarily set to 0 for page change
					if(!$page->id) {
						$this->error(
							sprintf($this->_('Unable to find page: %d'), $pageID)
						); 
					} else if(!$page->hasField($field)) {
						$this->error(
							sprintf($this->_('Page %d does not have field: %s'), $pageID, "$field")
						);
					} else if($commentField && !$commentField->allowCommentPage($comment, $page, true)) {
						// this one reports errors on its own
					} else {
						$this->message(
							sprintf($this->_('Moved comment #%1$d from page %2$d to page %3$d'), $comment->id, $comment->page->id, $pageID)
						);
						$properties['pages_id'] = $pageID;
						if($comment->parent_id) {
							$comment->parent_id = 0;
							$properties['parent_id'] = 0;
						}
						$changePage = $page;
						$numChanged++;
					}
					if($changePage === null) {
						// if page was not changed, restore back to original parent
						if($parentID) $comment->parent_id = $parentID;
					}
				}
			}
		
			$changeParentID = null;
			if($allowChangeParent) {
				// check for change of parent on threaded comment
				$parentID = $input->post("CommentParent$comment->id");
				if(strlen("$parentID") && ctype_digit("$parentID")) {
					// allows for parent_id "0" but ignore blank
					$parentID = (int) $parentID;
					if($parentID != $comment->parent_id) {
						if(!empty($properties['pages_id'])) {
							// we will apply the parent change after the Page change has applied
							$changeParentID = $parentID;
						} else {
							// parent ID has changed to another parent, or to no parent (0)
							if($commentField && $commentField->allowCommentParent($comment, $parentID, true)) {
								$comment->parent_id = $parentID;
								$properties['parent_id'] = $parentID;
								$numChanged++;
							}
						}
					}
				} else {
					$parentID = null;
				}
			}

			if(count($properties)) {
				$fieldtype->updateComment($comment->getPage(), $field, $comment, $properties); 	
				$this->message(sprintf($this->_('Updated comment #%d'), $comment->id) . " (" . implode(', ', array_keys($properties)) . ")"); 
			}
			
			if($changeParentID !== null && $changePage !== null) {
				// parent ID has changed at the same time that Page ID changed, so we apply parentID change afterwards
				$comment->setPage($changePage);
				if($commentField && $commentField->allowCommentParent($comment, $changeParentID, true)) {
					$comment->parent_id = $changeParentID;
					$fieldtype->updateComment($changePage, $field, $comment, array('parent_id' => $changeParentID));
					$numChanged++;
				}
			}
		}

		if($numDeleted || $numChanged) {
			$pageNum = $input->pageNum() > 1 ? 'page' . $input->pageNum() : '';
			$this->session->redirect('./' . $pageNum . $this->getQueryString());
		}
	}

	/**
	 * Render the markup for a single comment
	 * 
	 * Hookable since 3.0.204
	 * 
	 * @param Comment $comment
	 * @param array $options Options (since 3.0.204)
	 * @return string
	 *
	 */
	protected function ___renderComment(Comment $comment, array $options = array()) {
		
		$defaults = array(
			'prependMarkup' => '', 
			'appendMarkup' => '', 
			'prependContentMarkup' => '', 
			'appendContentMarkup' => '', 
		);
		
		$options = array_merge($defaults, $options);
		$sanitizer = $this->sanitizer;
		$page = $comment->getPage();
		$pageTitle = $sanitizer->entities1($page->get('title|name'));
		$field = $comment->getField();
		$adminTheme = $this->wire()->adminTheme;
		$isSuperuser = $this->user->isSuperuser();
		$allowDepth = $field->depth > 0;
		$allowDepthChange = $isSuperuser && $allowDepth;
		$allowPageChange = $isSuperuser;
		$parent = $comment->parent();
		$numChildren = 0;
		$text = $this->renderCommentText($comment);
		$id = $comment->id;
	
		/** @var JqueryUI $jQueryUI */
		$jQueryUI = $this->wire()->modules->get('JqueryUI');
		$jQueryUI->use('modal');
		
		$icons = array(
			'edit' => 'edit',
			'upvote' => 'arrow-up',
			'downvote' => 'arrow-down',
			'changed' => 'dot-circle-o',
			'reply' => 'angle-double-down',
			'replies' => 'angle-double-right',
			'pageEdit' => 'pencil', 
			'pageView' => 'external-link-square', 
			'commentEdit' => 'pencil',
			'commentReply' => 'reply',
			'meta' => 'sliders',
		);
		
		$outs = array(
			'status' => '',
			'notify' => '',
			'website' => '',
			'stars' => '',
			'votes' => '',
			'page' => '',
			'parent' => '',
			'reply' => '',
			'where' => '',
			'children' => '',
		);
		
		$classes = array(
			'input' => 'CommentInput',
			'textarea' => '',
			'radio' => '',
			'checkbox' => '',
			'table' => ''
		);
		
		$labels = array(
			'edit' => $this->_('edit'),
			'view' => $this->_('view'),
			'meta' => $this->_('meta'),
			'page' => $this->_('Page'),
			'date' => $this->_('When'),
			'status' => $this->_('Status'),
			'action' => $this->_('Action'),
			'cite' => $this->_('Cite'),
			'website' => $this->_('Web'),
			'email' => $this->_('Mail'),
			'none' => $this->_('None'),
			'parent' => $this->_('Parent'),
			'where' => $this->_('Where'),
			'reply' => $this->_('reply'),
			'replyTo' => $this->_('Reply to %s'),
			'stars' => $this->_('Stars'),
			'votes' => $this->_('Votes'),
			'notify' => $this->_('Notify'), 
			'commentId' => $this->_('Comment ID'), 
			'commentEdit' => $this->_('editor'),
		);

		$values = array(
			'cite' => $comment->cite, 
			'email' => $comment->email,
			'website' => $comment->website, 
			'ip' => $comment->ip, 
			'date' => wireDate($this->_('Y/m/d g:i a'), $comment->created), 
			'dateRelative' => wireDate('relative', $comment->created),
			'parent' => $parent && $parent->id ? $parent->id : '',
			'parentPlaceholder' => $parent && $parent->id ? '' : $labels['none'],
			'parentCite' => sprintf($labels['replyTo'], $labels['commentId']),
			'stars' => $comment->stars ? $comment->stars : '',
			'upvotes' => $comment->upvotes,
			'downvotes' => $comment->downvotes, 
			'page' => (int) "$comment->page",
		);
		
		$urls = array(
			'parent' => $parent ? "../all/?id=$parent->id" : '',
			'children' => "../all/?parent_id=$id",
			'siblings' => "../all/?pages_id=$page->id",
			'pageView' => "$page->url#Comment$id",
			'pageEdit' => $page->editUrl(),
			'metaEdit' => "../../../meta/?comment_id=$comment->id&amp;page_id=$page->id&amp;field_id=$field->id&amp;modal=1",
			'commentReply' => "../../../edit/?parent_id=$comment->id&amp;page_id=$page->id&amp;field_id=$field->id",
			'commentEdit' => "../../../edit/?comment_id=$comment->id&amp;page_id=$page->id&amp;field_id=$field->id",
			'email' => "./?email=" . urlencode($values['email']), 
			'cite' => "../all/?cite=" . urlencode($values['cite']),
			'ip' => "../all/?ip=" . urlencode($values['ip']),
		);
		
		$tooltips = array(
			'parent' => $this->_('ID of the Comment that this one is replying to.'), 
			'page' => $this->_('ID of the Page that this comment lives on.'), 
			'viewAll' => $this->_('View all having value'), 
			'viewPage' => $this->_('View page'), 
			'edit' => $this->_('Edit value'), 
			'editPage' => $this->_('Edit page'), 
			'pageFilter' => $this->_('Show only comments from page'), 
			'pageEdit' => $this->_('Edit page'),
			'pageView' => $this->_('View page'),
			'commentEdit' => $this->_('Comment editor'),
			'commentReply' => $this->_('Reply to this comment'), 
			'meta' => $this->_('View/edit metadata'), 
		);
		
		foreach($values as $key => $value) {
			$values[$key] = $sanitizer->entities($value);
		}
		
		foreach($icons as $key => $value) {
			$icons[$key] = wireIconMarkup($value, 'fw');
		}
		
		if($allowDepth) { 
			$children = $comment->children();
			$numChildren = count($children);
		}
		
		if($adminTheme instanceof AdminThemeFramework) {
			$classes['input'] = trim("$classes[input] " . $adminTheme->getClass('input-small'));
			$classes['textarea'] = $adminTheme->getClass('textarea');
			$classes['radio'] = $adminTheme->getClass('input-radio');
			$classes['checkbox'] = $adminTheme->getClass('input-checkbox');
			$classes['table'] = $adminTheme->getClass('table');
			$classes['select'] = $adminTheme->getClass('select-small');
			// if(strpos($classes['input'], 'uk-input') !== false) $classes['input'] .= " uk-form-blank";
		}
	
		$outs['status'] = "<select name='CommentStatus$id' class='CommentStatus $classes[select]'>";
		foreach($this->statusTranslations as $status => $label) {
			if($status == Comment::statusDelete && $numChildren) continue; 
			$selected = $comment->status == $status ? " selected='selected' " : '';
			$outs['status'] .= "<option value='$status'$selected>$label</option>";
			/*
			// $checked = $comment->status == $status ? "checked='checked' " : '';
			$outs['status'] .= 
				"<label class='CommentStatus'>" . 
					"<input class='$classes[radio]' type='radio' name='CommentStatus$id' value='$status' $checked/>&nbsp;" . 
					"<small>$label</small>" . 
				"</label>&nbsp; ";
			*/
		}
		$outs['status'] .= "</select>";

		if($page->editable()) {
			$text =
				"<div class='CommentTextEditable' id='CommentText$id' data-textarea-class='$classes[textarea]'>" .
					"<p>$text <a class='CommentTextEdit' href='#'>$icons[edit]&nbsp;$labels[edit]</a></p>" .
				"</div>";
		} else {
			$text = "<p>$text</p>";
		}
	
		if($allowPageChange) $outs['page'] =
			"<span class='detail ui-priority-secondary'>Page #</span>&nbsp;" .
			"<input class='$classes[input] pw-tooltip' title='$tooltips[page]' name='CommentPage$id' value='$values[page]' /> ";

		if($allowDepthChange) $outs['parent'] =
			"<span class='detail ui-priority-secondary'>" . $this->_('Reply to #') . "</span>&nbsp;" .
			"<input class='$classes[input] pw-tooltip' title='$tooltips[parent]' placeholder='$values[parentPlaceholder]' name='CommentParent$id' value='$values[parent]' />";
			
		if($outs['parent'] || $outs['page']) $outs['where'] =
			"<tr>" . 
				"<th>$labels[where]</th>" . 
				"<td class='CommentWhere'>$outs[page]$outs[parent]</td>" . 
			"</tr>";	
		
		if($values['website']) $outs['website'] = 
			"<tr>" .
				"<th>$labels[website]</th>" .
				"<td><a target='_blank' href='$values[website]'>$values[website]</a></td>" .
			"</tr>";
		
		if($field->useStars) $outs['stars'] =
			"<tr>" .
				"<th>$labels[stars]</th>" .
				"<td class='CommentStars'>" .
					"<input type='hidden' name='CommentStars$id' value='$values[stars]' />" .
					$comment->renderStars(array('input' => true)) .
				"</td>" .
			"</tr>";
		
		if($field->useVotes) $outs['votes'] =
			"<tr>" .
				"<th>$labels[votes]</th>" .
				"<td class='CommentVotes'>" .
					"<label class='CommentUpvotes'>" .
						"<span>$icons[upvote]</span>" .
						"<input class='$classes[input]' title='upvotes' type='number' min='0' name='CommentUpvotes$id' value='$values[upvotes]' />" .
					"</label> " .
					"<label class='CommentDownvotes'>" .
						"<span>$icons[downvote]</span>" .
						"<input class='$classes[input]' title='downvotes' type='number' min='0' name='CommentDownvotes$id' value='$values[downvotes]' />" .
					"</label> " .
				"</td>" .
			"</tr>";

		if($field->useNotify) {
			foreach($this->notifyFlagsTranslations as $flag => $label) {
				$checked = false;
				if($flag && $comment->flags & $flag) {
					$checked = true; // All or Replies
				} else if(!$flag && !($comment->flags & 2) && !($comment->flags & 4) && !($comment->flags & 8)) {
					$checked = true; // None
				}	
				$checked = $checked ? "checked='checked' " : '';
				$outs['notify'] .=
					"<label class='CommentNotify'>" .
						"<input class='$classes[radio]' type='radio' name='CommentNotify$id' value='$flag' $checked/>&nbsp;" .
						"<small>$label</small>" .
					"</label>&nbsp; ";
			}
			$outs['notify'] = "<tr><th>$labels[notify]</th><td>$outs[notify]</td></tr>";
		}
		
		if($parent) {
			$a = $sanitizer->entities($parent->cite) . " <a href='$urls[parent]'>$parent->id</a>";
			$outs['reply'] = // displayed after table
				"<p class='CommentReplyInfo detail'>" .
					"$icons[reply] " .
					sprintf($labels['replyTo'], $a) .
				"</p>";
		}

		if($numChildren) $outs['children'] = // displayed after table
			"<p class='CommentChildrenInfo detail'>" .
				"<a href='$urls[children]'>" .
					"$icons[replies] " .
					sprintf($this->_n('%d reply', '%d replies', $numChildren), $numChildren) .
				"</a>" .
			"</p>";

		/** @var FieldtypeComments $fieldtype */
		// $fieldtype = $field->type;
		// $who = $fieldtype->getNotifyEmails($page, $field, $comment); 
		// $text .= "<pre>" . htmlentities(print_r($who, true)) . "</pre>";
		$numRows = 0;
		foreach($outs as $out) if(!empty($out)) $numRows++;
		$contentClass = 'CommentContent';
		if($numRows >= 7) $contentClass .= ' CommentContentLarge';
		
		$meta = $comment->getMeta();
		$metaCnt = count($meta); 
		$metaTip = $tooltips['meta'] . ' (' . sprintf($this->_n('%d value', '%d values', $metaCnt), $metaCnt) . ')';

		$statusLinks = array(
			"<a class='pw-tooltip' title='$tooltips[commentEdit]' href='$urls[commentEdit]'>$icons[commentEdit] $labels[commentEdit]</a>",
			"<a class='pw-tooltip pw-modal' title='$metaTip' href='$urls[metaEdit]' data-buttons='button' data-close='button[name=submit_cancel]'>$icons[meta] $labels[meta]</a>",
		);
		if($comment->allowChildren()) {
			$statusLinks[] = "<a class='pw-tooltip' title='$tooltips[commentReply]' href='$urls[commentReply]'>$icons[commentReply] $labels[reply]</a>";
		}

		$out =
			"<div class='CommentItem ui-helper-clearfix CommentItemStatus$comment->status'>" . 
				$options['prependMarkup'] . 
				"<table class='CommentItemInfo $classes[table]' cellspacing='0'>" .
					"<tr class='CommentTitle'>" . 
						"<th>" .
							"<label>" .
								"<input class='CommentCheckbox $classes[checkbox]' type='checkbox' name='comment[]' value='$id' />&nbsp;" .
								"<span class='CommentID'>$id</span>" . 
							"</label>" . 
						"</th>" . 
						"<td>" . 
							"<a href='$urls[siblings]' class='pw-tooltip' title='$tooltips[pageFilter]'><strong>$pageTitle</strong></a> " .
							"<span class='detail'>&nbsp;" . 
								"<a class='detail pw-tooltip' title='$tooltips[pageView]' href='$urls[pageView]'>$labels[view]</a>&nbsp;/&nbsp;" . 
								"<a class='detail pw-tooltip' title='$tooltips[pageEdit]' href='$urls[pageEdit]'>$labels[edit]</a>" . 
							"</span>" . 
							"<span class='CommentChangedIcon'>$icons[changed]</span>" . 
						"</td>" . 
					"</tr>" .
					"<tr class='CommentItemStatus'>" .
						"<th>$labels[action]</th>" .
						"<td class='CommentStatus'>" . 
							$outs['status'] . " &nbsp;&nbsp;" . 
							implode('&nbsp;&nbsp;', $statusLinks) . 
						"</td>" .
					"</tr>" .
					$outs['notify'] . 
					"<tr>" . 
						"<th>$labels[date]</th>" . 
						"<td>$values[date] <span class='detail'>$values[dateRelative]</span></td>" . 
					"</tr>" . 
					"<tr>" .
						"<th>$labels[cite]</th>" . 
						"<td class='CommentCite'>" . 
							"<a href='$urls[cite]' class='pw-tooltip' title='$tooltips[viewAll]'>$values[cite]</a> " . 
							//"<input type='text' class='$classes[input]' name='CommentCite$id' value='$values[cite]' hidden /> " . // @todo
							//"<a href='#' class='CommentToggleSiblings pw-tooltip' title='$tooltips[edit]'>$icons[edit]</a> " .
							"<a class='detail pw-tooltip' title='$tooltips[viewAll]' href='$urls[ip]'>$values[ip]</a> " .
						"</td>" . 
					"</tr>" . 
					"<tr>" . 
						"<th>$labels[email]</th>" . 
						"<td>" .
							"<a href='$urls[email]' class='pw-tooltip' title='$tooltips[viewAll]'>$values[email]</a> " .
							//"<input type='email' class='$classes[input]' name='CommentEmail$id' value='$values[email]' hidden /> " . // @todo
							//"<a href='#' class='CommentToggleSiblings pw-tooltip' title='$tooltips[edit]'>$icons[edit]</a>" .
						"</td>" . 
					"</tr>" . 
					$outs['website'] . 
					$outs['stars'] . 
					$outs['votes'] . 
					$outs['where'] . 
				"</table>" .
				"<div class='$contentClass'>" .
					$options['prependContentMarkup'] . 
					"$outs[reply]" .
					"<div class='CommentText'>$text</div>" .
					"$outs[children]" .
					$options['appendContentMarkup'] . 
				"</div>" . 
				$options['appendMarkup'] . 
			"</div>";
	
		/*
		$out = 	
			"<div class='CommentItem ui-helper-clearfix CommentItemStatus{$comment->status}'>" . 
				"$out " . 
				"<div class='CommentContent'>" . 
					"$outs[parent]" . 
					"<div class='CommentText'>$text</div>" . 
					"$outs[children]" . 
				"</div>" . 
			"</div>";
		*/

		$page->of(false);

		return $out; 
	}

	/**
	 * Prep comment text for output in editor
	 * 
	 * @param Comment $comment
	 * @return string
	 * 
	 */
	protected function renderCommentText(Comment $comment) {
		$text = $this->sanitizer->entities($comment->get('text'));
		$text = str_replace('\r', ' ', $text);
		$text = preg_replace('/\r?(\n)/', '\r', $text);
		$text = str_replace('\r\r', "<br />\n<br />\n", $text);
		$text = str_replace('\r', "<br />\n", $text);
		return $text;
	}

	/**
	 * Render the comments list header
	 * 
	 * @param int $limit
	 * @param bool $useVotes
	 * @param bool $useStars
	 * @return string
	 * 
	 */
	protected function renderCommentsHeader($limit, $useVotes, $useStars) {
		
		$setStatusLabel = $this->_('Set status:');
		$perPageLabel = $this->_('per page');
		$adminTheme = $this->wire('adminTheme');
		$selectClass = $adminTheme instanceof AdminThemeFramework ? $adminTheme->getClass('select') : '';
		$checkboxClass = $adminTheme instanceof AdminThemeFramework ? $adminTheme->getClass('input-checkbox') : '';
		
		$pagerLimitOut = "
			<select class='$selectClass' id='CommentLimitSelect'>
				<option>10 $perPageLabel</option>
				<option>25 $perPageLabel</option>
				<option>50 $perPageLabel</option>
				<option>100 $perPageLabel</option>
			</select>
		";
		$pagerLimitOut = str_replace("<option>$limit ", "<option selected>$limit ", $pagerLimitOut);

		$checkAllLabel = $this->_('Check/uncheck all');
		$checkAll =
			"<label class='pw-tooltip' title='$checkAllLabel'><input class='$checkboxClass' type='checkbox' id='CommentCheckAll' /> " .
			"<span class='detail'></span></label>";

		$noCheckedLabel = $this->_('There are no checked items');
		$actionsOut =
			"<select class='$selectClass' id='CommentActions' data-nochecked='$noCheckedLabel'>" .
			"<option value=''>" . $this->_('Actions (checked items)') . "</option>";

		foreach($this->statusTranslations as $status => $label) {
			$actionsOut .= "<option value='$status'>$setStatusLabel $label</option>";
		}

		if($useVotes) {
			$actionsOut .= "<option value='reset-upvotes'>" . $this->_('Reset: Upvotes') . "</option>";
			$actionsOut .= "<option value='reset-downvotes'>" . $this->_('Reset: Downvotes') . "</option>";
		}
		$actionsOut .= "</select>";

		$sorts = array(
			'-created' => $this->_('Date (new–old)'),
			'created' => $this->_('Date (old–new)'),
		);
		if($useStars) {
			$sorts['-stars'] =  $this->_('Stars (high–low)');
			$sorts['stars'] = $this->_('Stars (low–high)');
		}
		if($useVotes) {
			$sorts['upvotes'] = $this->_('Upvotes');
			$sorts['downvotes'] = $this->_('Downvotes');
		}

		$sortByOut = "<select class='$selectClass' id='CommentListSort'>";
		$sortLabelPrefix = $this->_('Sort:');
		foreach($sorts as $sortKey => $sortLabel) {
			$sortByOut .= "<option value='$sortKey'>$sortLabelPrefix $sortLabel</option>";
		}
		$sortByOut .= "</select>";
		$sort = $this->wire('session')->getFor($this, 'sort');
		if(empty($sort)) $sort = "-created";
		$sortByOut = str_replace("'$sort'", "'$sort' selected", $sortByOut);

		return
			"<p class='CommentCheckAll'>$checkAll</p>" .
			"<p class='CommentActions'>$actionsOut</p>" .
			"<p class='CommentSorts'>$sortByOut</p>" .
			"<p class='CommentLimitSelect'>$pagerLimitOut</p>";
	}

	/**
	 * Render the markup for a list of comments
	 * 
	 * @param CommentArray $comments
	 * @return string
	 *
	 */
	protected function renderComments(CommentArray $comments) {
		
		$input = $this->wire()->input;

		$commentsBody = '';
		$cnt = 0;
		$status = $input->urlSegment3;
		$start = $comments->getStart();
		$limit = $comments->getLimit();
		$total = $comments->getTotal();
		$pageNumPrefix = $this->config->pageNumUrlPrefix; 
		$pageNum = $input->pageNum(); 
		$queryString = $this->getQueryString();
		$unsavedChangesLabel = $this->_('You have unsaved changes!');
		$field = $comments->getField();
		$pagesId = (int) $input->get('pages_id');
		
		if($pagesId) $this->breadcrumb("./$queryString", "Page $pagesId"); 

		foreach($comments as $comment) {
			/** @var Comment $comment */
			if($status && $status != 'all' && $this->statuses[$comment->status] != $status) continue; 
			$commentsBody .= $this->renderComment($comment, array()); 
			$cnt++;
			if($cnt >= $limit) break;
		}

		/** @var MarkupPagerNav $pager */
		$pager = $this->wire()->modules->get('MarkupPagerNav'); 
		$pagerOut = $pager->render($comments, array(
			'queryString' => $queryString,
			'baseUrl' => "./"
		));
		/** @var JqueryWireTabs $wireTabs */
		$wireTabs = $this->modules->get('JqueryWireTabs'); 
		$tabs = array();
		$class = $input->urlSegment3 === 'all' ? 'on' : '';
		$tabs["tabStatusAll"] = "<a class='$class' href='../all/$queryString'>" . $this->labelAll . "</a>";

		foreach($this->statuses as $status => $name) {
			if($status == Comment::statusDelete) continue;
			$class = $input->urlSegment3 === $name ? 'on' : '';
			$label = $this->statusTranslations[$status];
			if($label === $name) $label = ucfirst($label);
    		$tabs["tabStatus$status"] = "<a class='$class' href='../$name/$queryString'>$label</a>";
		}

		$tabsOut = $wireTabs->renderTabList($tabs);
		if($total) {
			$this->headline .= ' (' . ($start + 1) . "–" . ($start + $cnt) . " " . sprintf($this->_('of %d'), $total) . ')';
		} else {
			$this->headline .= ' (0)';
		}
		$this->headline($this->headline);

		if($cnt) { 
			/** @var InputfieldSubmit $button */
			$button = $this->modules->get('InputfieldSubmit');
			$button->attr('name', 'processComments');
			$button->showInHeader();
			$button = $button->render();
		} else $button = '';

		if($input->pageNum > 1) {
			$queryString = "./$pageNumPrefix$pageNum$queryString";
		}

		if(!count($comments)) {
			return
				"<form>" . 
					$tabsOut . 
					"<h2>" . $this->_('None to display') . "</h2>" . 
				"</form>";
		}
		
		$commentsHeader = $this->renderCommentsHeader($limit, $field->get('useVotes'), $field->get('useStars'));
		
		return
			"<form id='CommentListForm' action='$queryString' method='post' data-unsaved='$unsavedChangesLabel'>" . 
				$tabsOut . 
				"<div id='CommentListHeader' class='ui-helper-clearfix'>" . 	
					$pagerOut . 
					$commentsHeader . 
				"</div>" . 
				"<div class='CommentItems ui-helper-clearfix'>" . 
					$commentsBody . 
				"</div>" . 
				$pagerOut . 
				$button . 
			"</form>"; 
	}
	
	protected function getQueryString() {
		$queryString = '';
		foreach($this->input->whitelist as $key => $value) {
			$queryString .= $this->wire('sanitizer')->entities($key) . "=" . $this->wire('sanitizer')->entities($value) . "&";
		}
		$queryString = trim($queryString, '&');
		if($queryString) $queryString = "?$queryString";
		return $queryString;
	}

	/**
	 * Apply the "notify" flag value to comment
	 * 
	 * @param Comment $comment
	 * @param int $notify
	 * @return bool Returns true if flags were changed, false if not
	 * 
	 */
	protected function applyCommentNotifyFlag(Comment $comment, $notify) {
		
		$notify = (int) $notify;
		$flags = $comment->flags;
		$flagsPrev = $flags;
		
		if($notify === 0 && $comment->flags) {
			// remove flag
			if($comment->flags & Comment::flagNotifyAll) $flags = $flags & ~Comment::flagNotifyAll; // remove
			if($comment->flags & Comment::flagNotifyReply) $flags = $flags & ~Comment::flagNotifyReply; // remove
			if($comment->flags & Comment::flagNotifyConfirmed) $flags = $flags & ~Comment::flagNotifyConfirmed; // remove
			
		} else if($notify === Comment::flagNotifyAll && !($flags & Comment::flagNotifyAll)) {
			if($flags & Comment::flagNotifyReply) $flags = $flags & ~Comment::flagNotifyReply; // remove
			$flags = $flags | Comment::flagNotifyAll; // add
			
		} else if($notify === Comment::flagNotifyReply) {
			if($flags & Comment::flagNotifyAll) $flags = $flags & ~Comment::flagNotifyAll; // remove
			$flags = $flags | Comment::flagNotifyReply; // add
		}
	
		if($notify && !$comment->id) {
			// comments added in admin do not need email confirmation
			$flags = $flags | Comment::flagNotifyConfirmed;
		}
		
		if($flags != $flagsPrev) {
			$comment->flags = $flags;
			return true;
		}
	
		return false;
	}

	protected function checkInstall() {
		if($this->wire('modules')->isInstalled('ProcessLatestComments')) {
			$this->warning('Please uninstall the ProcessLatestComments module (this module replaces it).');
		}
	}

	public function ___install() {
		$this->checkInstall();
		parent::___install();
	}
	
	/**
	 * Search for items containing $text and return an array representation of them
	 *
	 * Implementation for SearchableModule interface
	 *
	 * @param string $text Text to search for
	 * @param array $options Options to modify behavior:
	 *  - `edit` (bool): True if any 'url' returned should be to edit items rather than view them
	 *  - `multilang` (bool): If true, search all languages rather than just current (default=true).
	 *  - `start` (int): Start index (0-based), if pagination active (default=0).
	 *  - `limit` (int): Limit to this many items, if pagination active (default=0, disabled).
	 * @return array
	 *
	 */
	public function search($text, array $options = array()) {
		
		$sanitizer = $this->wire()->sanitizer;
		$page = $this->getProcessPage();
		$commentFields = array();
		
		foreach($this->wire()->fields as $field) {
			/** @var Field $field */
			if($field->type instanceof FieldtypeComments) $commentFields[$field->name] = $field;
		}

		$result = array(
			'title' => $page->id ? (string) $page->title : $this->className(),
			'total' => 0,
			'url' => '',
			'items' => array(),
			'properties' => array(
				'text',
				'cite',
				'email',
				'status',
				'created',
				'website',
				'ip',
				'user_agent',
				'upvotes',
				'downvotes',
				'stars'
			)
		);
		
		if($options['help']) return $result;
		
		$operator = empty($options['operator']) ? '%=' : $options['operator'];
		$value = $sanitizer->selectorValue($text); 	
		$summaryLength = $options['verbose'] ? 1024 : 200;
		
		if(!empty($options['property'])) {
			$selector = "$options[property]$operator$value";
			$q = "$options[property]$operator$text"; 
		} else {
			$selector = "text$operator$value";
			$q = "text$operator$text"; 
		}
		
		if(!empty($options['limit'])) $selector .= ", limit=$options[limit]";
		if(!empty($options['start'])) $selector .= ", start=$options[start]";
	
		foreach($commentFields as $field) {
			/** @var CommentField $field */
			/** @var CommentArray $comments */
			$comments = $field->type->find($selector); 
			if(!count($comments)) continue;
			$result['total'] += $comments->getTotal();
			$url = $page->url() . "list/$field->name/all/";
			if(count($commentFields) === 1) {
				$result['url'] = $url . "?q=" . urlencode($q);
			}
			foreach($comments as $comment) {
				/** @var Comment $comment */
				$commentPage = $comment->getPage();
				$editUrl = $url . "?id=$comment->id";
				$item = array(
					'id' => $comment->id,
					'name' => $comment->cite,
					'title' => $comment->cite, 
					'subtitle' => $commentPage && $commentPage->id ? (string) $commentPage->get('title|name') : '', 
					'summary' => $sanitizer->truncate($comment->text, $summaryLength), 
					'url' => empty($options['edit']) ? $comment->url() : $editUrl
				);
				$result['items'][] = $item;
			}
		}

		/* // for debugging:
		$result['items'][] = array(
			'id' => 0,
			'name' => '',
			'title' => $selector,
			'subtitle' => '',
			'summary' => '',
			'url' => '#'
		);
		*/

		return $result;
	}


}